Mr Cameron’s Anti-immigrant Rant: The Back Story

john weeksLast week The Guardian reported that the EU Commissioner for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion, László Andor, cautioned David Cameron about stigmatizing immigrants from other European countries as taking excessive and gratuitous advantage of British public services (Guardian, 25 March 2013). In an article in the right-wing Sun newspaper on the same day, the Prime Minister wrote, “Sun readers know that immigration got out of control under Labour”.

The anti-immigrant statements of the Prime Minister follow on from the recent strong electoral performance of the United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP), which has positioned itself well to the right of the Conservatives (leaving it very far to the Right, indeed). The inflammatory and irresponsible polemics by the Prime Minister are all the more dangerous because of a clear increase in such prejudice in the public.  My cottage in rural Hampshire is positioned in the heartland of troglodyte Tory-ism, and I frequently encounter assertions that Romanians,Poles,etc. are responsible for local unemployment, housing shortages and any other social malady that strikes the speaker.

Commissioner Andor and many others have pointed to the benefits that immigrants bring to the United Kingdom (and almost every country), but such arguments fall on deaf ears, and not just among UKIP supporters. Immigrant-bashing occurs in most countries at most times, but over the last few years in Britain its receptive audience has grown substantially.

It appears that this increase in anti-immigrant xenophobia cannot be explained by increases in immigration itself, as the chart below indicates.  By definition we have no reliable information on unmeasured immigration (“illegal”), but the statistics available suggest that numbers declined in the second half of the 2000′s.  This seems consistent with rising unemployment in the United Kingdom, implying fewer job opportunities.

Net inflow of legally entering immigrants to the United Kingdom, 2000-2010 (thousands)

p1

Source: www.oecd.org

Yet surveys of opinion in Britain indicate a substantial increase in the number of people who consider immigration a “problem”, to a level higher than for other large EU countries. The reasons for popular concern about immigration are not hard to identify. For example, a frequent complaint is that immigrants take away jobs from British citizens and this drives wages down.

The chart below measures the unemployment rate compared to its minimum value during 2000-2012, and average weekly real earnings relatively to its value of the same time (the third quarter of 2004 when unemployment was 4.6 percent). By the end of the decade the unemployment rate was up to eight percent. Average earnings, after rising continuously until the first quarter of 2008, at the end of 2012 were below their level of eight years before.

To put the matter simply, when a recession hits, job opportunities disappear and wages fall. Suddenly, the economic reality shifts from “more than enough for all” to “not enough to go around”. When this shift occurs xenophobia latent in society asserts itself, especially if leaders give it legitimacy. This government attempt to blame immigrants for the economic woes of the vast majority in Britain borders on the venal. It is the government itself that through its fiscal policy perpetuates the unemployment and falling incomes that lend credibility to the xenophobia.

Untitled

United Kingdom unemployment and average private weekly earnings, compared to mid-2004, 2000-2012

Note: Unemployment is measured as the percentage point difference from the 3rd quarter of 2004, and average real earnings as the percent difference from that quarter.

Source: UK Office of National Statistics (wages) and OECD (unemployment)

Another frequent complaint about immigrants is that they compete with citizens for scarce housing. This often goes along with anecdotal tales of immigrants enjoying priority over citizens in access to public housing. It is quite likely that such competition is reality, but the xenophobic prejudices identify the wrong cause. Were every migrant expelled, the majority of Britons would suffer from shortages of housing, manifested in long waiting lists and high prices. This is because of a disastrous decline in publicly funded housing construction since 2007 (see chart below).

During the last eighteen months of the Brown government publicly funded housing construction began a recovery, which the coalition government quickly terminated.  By the end of 2012 public housing expenditure stagnated a full thirty percent below its value in the third quarter of 2004.  Even privately funded housing, most of which is for families well above median income, stagnated. At the end of 2012 it was lower than eight years before.

We should not be surprised that accusing immigrants of taking housing from UK citizens gains credibility among the public when neither the public nor the private sector constructs much new housing. Population increases, existing houses deteriorates, and the government reduces residential construction.  The issue is not immigration, but government policy.

p3

Public and Private expenditure on housing construction, constant prices, 2000-2012 (relatively to 3rd quarter of 2004, percentages)

Note: Measured as percentage difference from 3rd quarter of 2004.

Source: UK Office of National Statistics

In the United Kingdom immigration is not out of control. The government is out of control of the voters than brought it into office. In pursuit of legitimization of its reactionary assault on social provision, and the public sector in general, the government transfers blame from itself with xenophobic polemics. Whether recent immigrants make a net contribution to the United Kingdom pales compared to the question of whether the current government’s social balance is positive or negative.  The answer is, overwhelmingly negative.

  • James Laurie

    I have no idea who this Gentleman is but could I with respect suggest he takes his head out from his own backside. If unlike the vast majority of British people he
    can not see the harm immigration is doing to this country he is fool in spite of the letters behind his name.

  • http://www.facebook.com/melow.meldrew Melow Meldrew

    The UK cannot take any more migrants or illegals from Europe, this is basic common sense, the European Union is abusing its own policy and ushering these people ever onwards to the UK all the time, the UK has nothing to apologise FOR. The gravy train is ending for Europeans in the UK. We LIVE here, the migration IS out of control, they are depriving UK residents of work and this creates conflict too, we are NOT in the business of setting up little Europe in the UK. At some point freedom of movement will stop at Calais. Cannot come too soon for us. The only issue we in the UK have, is Cameron has not yet put the borders back up and stopped any more coming here until we deport the 700,000 we know about who should not be here anyway. We’ve 15yrs of illegal migrants to get rid of first. Play your euro violin some place else. Party over.

    • Kathleen McMullen

      Unfortunately many of the Poles, Czechs, Latvians and Slovaks have gone home! Now there are only whiny UKIP members for neighbours. It will be awful if more migrants leave.

  • http://www.facebook.com/melow.meldrew Melow Meldrew

    One suspects he belongs to the human rights ‘let’s rip off the UK’ area, there has been millions of pounds made by fighting for the rights of terrorists like Hook, free loaders from the eastern bloc claiming cash from the UK to post to families abroad, and hordes of downright illegals coming here,most with no job prospects. Europe is encouraging the swamping of the UK with migrants who are destroying the support, educational, health, and access systems in the UK. If Europe is so bad their populations want to come to the UK then something is wrong with Europe. I suggest it is because it is the European union,run by Germany and France dictating to the rest.

  • Wombat

    What a silly man.

  • Paul

    Hospitals are over-crowded; roads are over-crowded; primary-school classrooms are increasingly over-crowded; the country’s over-crowded. We’re full, yet an increasing fertility rate and mass immigration will continue to make a sizeable contribution to a population that will hit 70 million over the next 15-20 years.

    The people of these islands were never consulted as to whether they wished to see mass immigration into the country, and they certainly didn’t give their consent to this imposition. Enough’s enough! Thankfully, ordinary people like me now have a party to vote for that ‘says it as it is’: UKIP.